There’s nothing better than an episode of The Vampire Diaries featuring the best member of the original family, Elijah. Actually, that’s not true: the best ones have flashback hair. But although “American Gothic” featured a modern-day eldest Original brother, it still managed to be an excellent episode — thanks in large part to the hour’s many dynamic duos.
The race to find the cure isn’t quite as interesting now that Elena’s a vampire biyotch, but it got a lot more fun when she teamed up with Rebekah to hunt down Katherine. Ms. Pierce was holed up in a small town in Pennsylvania, where she’d compelled the natives to let her feed off of them and forget her immediately after. Elena and Rebekah managed to catch her and keep her hostage in a diner (thanks to a grisly fork-to-hand impalement situation), sending Elena to a mysterious meeting in her place.
RELATED: ‘The Vampire Diaries’ Recap: Elena’s Hungry for Cheerleaders
Who was that meeting with, you might ask. Who’s “em,” the person in Kat’s calendar? Apparently, Katherine DGAF about punctuation, and those were the initials of one Elijah Mikaelson, general badass m-f’er and Katherine’s boyfriend. HER BOYFRIEND. Which we found out when Elijah greeted Elena-as-Katherine with a kiss. The sight of Elijah and Elena kissing was both weird and amazing, probably because the idea of Elijah kissing anyone makes a gal all tingly inside. He figured it out, though, and then they kind of hung out while Katherine ran some game in the diner.
While all this was happening, Stefan and Damon had finally chased their runaway Carmen Sandiegos to the Pennsylvania wilds. Katherine promised to take them (and Rebekah) to the house where the cure was hidden. After Katherine pretended it was stolen, Damon realized the vial was actually sitting on the bottom of a vervain-laced fish tank. Through a series of super-fast vampire moves, Katherine ended up escaping as Rebekah caught the vial before it crashed to the floor. Without a second thought, the original vampire downed the shot and promptly fainted.
First of all, how was she so sure it would work? Second of all, wouldn’t she want to consider her options now that she actually had the cure in her possession? She took that shot faster than a Disney girl on spring break (sprang break foreverrr). Unfortunately, because this is Katherine we’re talking about, it was fake, and Rebekah was crushed when she woke up.
RELATED: ‘The Vampire Diaries’ Recap: Is [Spoiler] Really Dead?
In an interesting play, Katherine ended up returning to her boyf and giving him the actual cure (after he found out she lied to him, prompting Elena and everyone else’s inner monologue to respond with a well-timed “DUH”). Is it because she actually loves him, or is she playing a long con? Personally, I’m really not sure that Katherine can be trusted. While some part of her probably does love Elijah, there’s no way she gave him the real cure purely out of good will. Girlfriend’s got something brewing. The question is what? And the follow-up question: what will Elijah do with the cure? Stefan and Damon, defeated once again, sat with Elena in the small town’s diner and finally discussed their real wishes for her. Only Elena had some wishes of her own — she wanted them to quit it with their pesky meddling and let her live her emotion-free life. If they didn’t stop sticking their noses in her business, she’d start killing innocents — starting with the diner waitress who happened to pass by their table at the wrong time. No Emotion Elena might be a killer, but she’s also a badass. Will they listen to her reasoning?
The other part of the episode focused on Joseph Morgan shirtless, writing around on the floor. He enlisted Caroline’s help in getting the white oak splinter out of his back, but the first time it wasn’t actually Caroline, it was Silas disguised as Caroline. The second time, when it actually was Caroline, she managed to be super rightfully pissed off at him while still doing him a favor and digging into his back with garden shears (with some super gross sound effects to make it seem all the more real). It made sense, though, because if Klaus dies then the rest of our Mystic Falls vampires die too, and nobody wants that to happen.
RELATED: ‘The Vampire Diaries’ Boss on Elena’s ‘Tsunami of Grief’
But the real twist (not the twisting of metal into Klaus’ back) came when Caroline distracted Klaus from his pain enough to make him realize there was no splinter, it was all an illusion created by Silas. Klaus told Caroline that although he wouldn’t call off his hunt for Tyler, he wasn’t exactly scouring the ends of the Earth for him. It’s probably safe to assume Tyler will be fine for the time being.
As for the other two main cast Mystic Falls residents, Bonnie wasn’t in the episode at all (pro! She’s not off my s*** list after that Silas/Shane nonsense.) — but neither was Matt (con! He’s so cute.).
Lingering thoughts:
-Do we really believe that Stefan will disappear from Elena’s life when she turns her humanity back on?
-Elijah!!!!!!(!!!!!) (Still exciting.)
-This was one of Season 4’s better episodes, Y/Y?
-Why is it still so painful to relive Jeremy’s death in the “previously on” segments? It’s been, like, months.
Follow Jean on Twitter @hijean
[Photo Credit: The CW]
You Might Also Like:
Topanga’s Revealing Lingerie Shoot: Hello ’90s! 
13 Most WTF Fan Tributes
